Wednesday, August 6, 2014

A Kiss Goodbye

Poolesville Presbyterian Church
06.15.14; Rev. David Williams


Scripture Lessons: Matthew 28:16-20; 2 Corinthians 13:11-13




I was never particularly good at saying goodbye.


When I was a tiny little pup, no more than four or five, I can still remember how much trouble I’d have whenever the time came for saying goodbye.  That was particularly true at parties.  The day would come, and I’d be psyched.  Oh, I’d be a gracious host.  It’d be wonderful to have my friends there, and I’d always be completely on my best behavior.  Games would be played.  Cookies...or better yet, cake..would be eaten.  More games would be played.  There would be presents.  We’d run around, and it’d be fun, and then, well, then their parents would show up.  Which meant it was all coming to an end.


This would be the point where, had I been a tiny little Mr. Manners, I would have pleasantly ushered each of my friends to their waiting parental transport pod like the miniature host of some Victorian-era salon.  “Thank you so very much for coming!  It was absolutely lovely.  I do hope that we might be able to do this again sometime very soon.  Give my regards to your family, if you would.”


That was not my reaction.  As I realized that the time we’d been spending together was coming to an end, it was like a switch had been thrown in my little head.  Click, it would go, and then things would change.  I have vague memories of inconsolable weeping and flopping around.  It was tears and snot and piteous wailing, which I’m sure made the very best of impressions on the parents who were picking up their children.


“Is...is someone killing a cat next door?”  “No, no, that’s the birthday boy,” my parents would say, as I tantrumed incoherently.


As the years passed, I’m not sure I got much better at it.  Like, say, when the time came to part from my high school girlfriend, as I left her...and our relationship...after a trip out West to help her move to the other side of the country.  I was fine for about the first minute or so sitting on the plane to come back home, and then, well, there were the tears and the snot and the piteous wailing again.


“Is someone killing a cat back there,” the pilot must have said to the stewardess over the intercom.  “No, no,” she would have said.  “I’ve got no idea what’s wrong with that kid.”


It’s hard getting the closure thing just right, especially if things are challenging, and especially if you’re not entirely sure when you will come back into the presence of the one you’re with.  When you’ve shared life with them, they become part of your story, part of that Book of You that’s being written into the fabric of creation.  They’re part of you, just as you’re part of them, and there are some stories you just never want to end.


In that leave taking, you want to carry them with you, and for...in the goodbye you share...something to be passed on between you that brings your time together to the best possible close.


There are two such leave-takings in our readings today from the Gospels and the Epistles.


The first we find as Jesus prepared to move on, in the final moments of the Gospel of Matthew.  It’s a leave-taking that Matthew uses to sum things up for the shared story of Jesus and those of us who have chosen to follow his Way.  Unlike Mark, who ended his story bluntly and abruptly, in fear and confusion, or Luke, who carries on the tale through the story of the early church, this is is as far as things run in Matthew.  These are parting words, the end of things, the place where the story ends and we part ways while Vera Lynn sings “We’ll Meet Again” wistfully in the background.


Into that place, Jesus speaks confidently about his connectedness to those he’s brought into community around him.  Yes, the story of their time together may seem to be ending.  But in their commitment to live and to teach the life that he brought them into connection with, there was a deeper bond...one that would not pass or fade or change.


Go out with confidence, he said.  Know that you and I are now part of something that will always be, until everything that we know passes away.


And then there’s the second leave taking, the one we hear at the very end of Paul’s Second letter to the church at Corinth.  Paul hadn’t exactly had the easiest of relationships with the messy and conflict ridden community at Corinth, and here we get the last of the correspondences that history retains about that often awkward, often contentious relationship.


All had not been well in Corinth, as Paul struggled to get them to stop fighting and tearing at one another.  As he leaves them, he knows that they may choose to live according to the way that he’d taught them.  Or not.  Corinthians were pretty good at the “or not” part.


As he closes out his letter, Paul leaves the Corinthians with a word of encouragement that is also a word of challenge.  When he asks them to put things in order, to finally stop their insistence on factions and infighting, he’s taking that one last moment to remind them of the very thing that’s been his hope for them all along.  Live into God’s grace, he says.  Find a way to be gracious to one another.


Live in peace, he says, and the God of love and peace will be with you.  And sure, there’s an implicit flip-side to those words.  Keep things chaotic, don’t listen to me, endlessly fight and war with each other, and y’all are just out of luck.
But he chooses not to say that, as tempting as it must have been.  He chooses to depart not with a swift parting kick, but with a good word.


Even in the face of a community that’s been a serious and sustained pain in the backside, Paul’s words of leavetaking are very intentionally chosen to be graceful.  He doesn’t lose sight of the reason he has walked with them, hoped for them, and struggled with them.


Which is why, as hard as his words have been with them, his leavetaking takes the form of a benediction--a familiar one, I might add.  His hope is that the relationship that they’ve had will still be part of who they are.  His hope, having shown both grace and challenge, is that they’ll understand the purpose of everything they’ve shared.


This is, for so many, a season of leave-taking.  In our endlessly churning culture, we never know when we might be moved on.  But with the coming of summer comes the time for moving on from the places and faces we’ve known.  It’s a time of graduation and advancement, and as hoped for as all of those things are, there comes with them the reality of a story’s end.


If you’re moving on from one school to another, or moving on from college, the fabric of your relationships--the day in, day out presence of those around you--is going to change.  If you’re not moving on, precious others are.  That face and that voice and that presence that has been a part of your life since the moment it came into the world may soon not be part of your every day.


I’m aware that, myself, as a father, every time I wrap my arms around my children who are no longer children.  That little boy I used to carry on my shoulders to bed after storytime now is a man who smiles down at me from broad shoulders.  The time they set themselves out into the world is a few short years still to come, but it’s just a few now, close enough that I can feel it.   


Which is why, frankly, I think it’s better to preach this sermon now when that reality is a few years out, rather than to try to choke out these words when my little tiny ones are just about to leave.  I’d rather not subject you to the tears and the mucus and the piteous wailing.


“Is someone killing a cat up there,” a guest will ask one of you.  “No, no, that’s just the pastor.”


But in the words I know I’ll struggle to offer them, I’m hoping that I’ll remember the way that both Paul and our shared teacher took their leave from those they loved.  They spoke from the certainty that the time that they had shared with the people who they loved was forever woven into God’s story of us together.  We remain forever part of one another, wherever love and peace abides.


I am with you always, says our Teacher.


That truth of grace, love, and communion is one we should remember, no matter when those times of leaving come.


Let that be so, for you and for me, AMEN.









Friday, June 20, 2014

Do As I Do

Poolesville Presbyterian Church
05.18.14; Rev. David Williams


Scripture Lesson: John 14:1-14




How do we understand ourselves?  How do we articulate that understanding into the world?


Most of us have a picture of who we are in our minds, one that we knit together out of all of the different things we believe about ourselves.  I am, we say, and then there’s a blank, and we fill in the blank.


I am a human being, you might say.  I am left-handed, you might say, if you weren’t me.   I am fabulously fashion-forward, you might say, if you also weren’t me.  When we say we are something, we’re expressing--if we’re being accurate--something about the nature of who we are.


When we really talk about who we are, what that statement is not is a statement of what we believe about ourselves.  Sure, it can speak to an aspiration or a hope.  But if we talk about ourselves in terms of what we believe to be true, but that aren’t quite exactly totally real yet, then we’re not making a meaningful statement.


Like a year or so back, say, when I’d finally decided to follow through on something I’d believed about myself for years.  “I am an aikido master,” I would think to myself.  I was sure that in there somewhere, there were latent aikido skills that would require only the slightest attempt to reveal that I was almost supernaturally gifted in that particular martial art.  It’s a peculiar martial art, aikido is.  It’s almost completely nonviolent.  It’s meditative, but not quite like tai chi.  Like judo, it involves taking the energy of an opponent in a conflict and applying it to the task of having them lying unharmed on the ground.


As martial arts go, it’s a little mystic, sort of a Jedi thing.  “This is not the standing position you were looking for.  Move along.”  But I never quite got around to it when I was younger and working, and then, well, kids came along.  But still in my mind, there rested the certainty: “I am an aikido master.”  As my boys grew up from tiny spuds to the towering largelings they have become, I pictured going with with them to some hidden lair of aikido masters, where we would together learn the ways of that mystic order.


In my mind, I’d played the whole thing out.  “Join me, my son,” I would say, and then we’d go on a Father Son Jedi outing, preferably without all that Skywalker family drama.  I talked it up, and the big guy was up for it.


When my oldest turned fourteen, he and I began that journey.  We found a lair of aikido masters hidden away in a warehouse complex, and then began our training.  “I am an aikido master,” I said to myself, radiant with mystic certainty.  That lasted all of about five minutes.  Thump thump, I went, as the instructors attempted to teach me to fall.  Focus your energies and make yourself a circle, they would say, rolling across the mats as smoothly as if they were the aforementioned circle. “Just do that,” they’d say.  Thump thump, I’d go.  “No, that’s a square,” the instructor would say, and they’d inscribe another perfect circle on the mat.  “Do that,” they’d say.  Thump thump, I’d go.  “I think that’s a triangle,” the instructor would say.  “Are you alright,” the instructor would say.


I was not going to magically be an aikido master.  It was not going to happen simply because I held it in my mind.  And if we do not do the thing we say we believe, it does not matter whether we believe it about ourselves.


Which is, I think, one of the things we most easily forget when we say the words: “I am a Christian.”


Here, we tend to think of this in terms of certain things that we believe to be true.  We are Christian because we hold to thus and such, or because we believe thus and such.   The challenge, though, is that such a way of thinking is a great way to insure that we spend very little time actually being the human beings Jesus challenges us to be, and instead spend all of our time squabbling about things on the interwebs.


This passage comes to us at the beginning of the ending of John’s Gospel.  At the end of chapter 13, John has given us the last supper--or rather, his version of it.  Jesus has just washed the feet of his disciples, showing himself to be completely humble--as if he were their servant.  It was his way of showing his love for them, and reminding them that their primary task was to be servants of one another.  He notes to Peter that despite his protestations to the contrary, he’s going to betray him.  Then he sends Judas off to begin the whole betrayal process, and that brings us to where our reading begins.


Jesus is confronted with the questions of his disciples, who are sensing that something big is about to happen.  When Jesus starts saying that he’s going to prepare a place for them, they get a little fuddled.  Oh, sure, he just said that they knew the way there, but in that pre-GPS era, things must have felt a little bit dicey.


It falls to Thomas to say, Lord, we just don’t know that place.  How are we supposed to get there if we’re not even sure how to get there?


To that, John’s Jesus does not mince words:  “I am the way.”  He’s also the truth and the life, and in the face of Thomas and his struggles to come to terms with what that means, Jesus lays out a pretty straightforward measure for how you get there.  Here, he is saying to Thomas.  Look at me.  See how I am.  See how I teach, how I live, and how I relate to you.  If you see that, and you know that, then you know the way.  All you have to do is act on it.


This passage, though, tends to get spun other ways.  We interpret these words of teaching welcome as meaning something very, very different.  Here Jesus has just shown the way.  He is in the presence of his disciples, showing them the depth of his love for them--which, if you read what the Beloved Disciple wrote, is the entire point of this whole story.


But instead of looking to what we know--deep in ourselves, with our minds and our hearts and our whole selves--about Jesus and letting that be our guide on the path, we look instead to other things.  Our knowledge of the Way becomes not about our deeply wrought sense of who Jesus was, and drifts into abstractions.   Do you believe exactly the right things about how to interpret the Bible?  Do you hold to the correct set of theological datapoints?  Do you affirm the infralapsarian position taught in the Canons of Dort?


Jesus does not mention the infralapsarian position taught in the Canons of Dort to Thomas, or to Philip, probably because he doesn’t want to make Thomas weep uncontrollably.


He says, look to me and how who I am shapes what I do.  Hear my voice.  See my actions.  I spend time with those who our culture curses.  I will not raise the sword in anger.  I get down on my knees, and show with my hands and my care that I love you.


That, as we attempt to claim ourselves as Christians, is the key challenge we face.  We may believe many things about ourselves.  We are good people.  We are right with God.  Our understanding of the faith is the best possible way to be,


But if our actions do not tell the truth of that, if we are bitter and hateful, self-absorbed and anxious, unforgiving and unloving, then we know neither Jesus nor the Way.  Our task, if we are to be disciples, is to change that in ourselves.  We should work with the Spirit of God as it moves in us, so that those who see us will see, and so that they’ll know.


Let that be so, for you and for me, AMEN.





Friday, May 23, 2014

Let Me Count The Ways

Sermon Title: Let Me Count The Ways
Poolesville Presbyterian Church
05.11.14; Rev. David Williams


Scripture Lesson:  John 10:1-10




We’ve started reaching the point where I’m struggling to help my kids with their homework.


Perhaps I should rephrase that.  We are reaching the point when they’ve both grown up so much that I can’t help either one of them with their work.  


I was never exactly the best of folks when it came to getting homework done.  I’d developed a profound skill at looking like I was doing homework, though.  I would diligently settle into my room to read, immersing myself in the vital study of Camus and Sartre and Doestoevsky, which would have been great if they’d had anything to do with any class I was actually taking.  I would sit there with my geometry textbook on one hand, and a piece of paper on the other.  There I am, ready to study.  But somehow when those equations passed from the text through my brain and out my hand onto the page, they came out on the page looking like pencil drawings of jacked-up ‘71 Chevelles.  The human mind is an incredible thing.


When it came time to get around to getting my work done, it’d tend to be a frantic rush on the bus or in the five minutes before class started.


Hey...what’d you get for question three?  Cool. That’s just what I got!  What about questions four through ten?


I finally mastered high school math well after high school, when I had to reteach it to myself to take grad school exams.  And there, the way I learned on my own was to find the replicable pattern for any particular type of equation.  Look at one problem.  Look at another problem.  Grasp the principle that moves you from one step to another, and bam...every problem after that is remarkably straightforward.


It’s a clear path, the cleanest and simplest way to get from the problem to the resolution.  Which, as I see it, is the whole point of doing a math problem in the first place.  Find the path to the outcome.


My older son has already moved well past my outer threshold mathematically, but I also struggle with my younger one’s work.  What’s most challenging is finding that simple rule, that most elemental solution, as I work my way through the thickets of complexity in his textbooks.  I can do it, still, but I don’t recall it being as hard to find the basic patterns.  Here’s one way to to it, the text says.  Here’s another way.  And wait, here’s a way to write it out.  And here’s a concept map.  And here’s a clown, acting it out with puppets.


Eventually, it’s in there, but there are so many different ways presented that getting through to the simplest solution path seems like a struggle.


The idea, of course, is that there are many different ways that human beings learn.  Some learning is more visual.  Some folks operate more conceptually, and some are more kinesthetic.  The challenge comes when we try to find our way when there seem to be a thousand different possible paths.  How do we get down to that which is the most essential?  How do we get to where we’re yearning to be in life, if we’re not even quite sure where we’re headed or how to get there?


That’s the peculiar tension that plays out through the reading from John’s Gospel today, where we see Jesus wrapped up in conversation with Pharisees.  This little passage picks up where the last story we heard from John left off.  He’s just been in the middle of a conversation with a blind man that had been healed, a conversation that seemed to slam the Pharisees, when some Pharisees nearby interjected.


And suddenly, Jesus is sort of telling a story.  Sort of.  This is John’s Gospel, after all, and the way that John tells us about Jesus is different from the way that the other three Gospels pitch out that message.  If it’s Mark, Matthew, or Luke...particularly Matthew and Luke...the stories come fast and furious.  


There’s one parable after another, headspinning tales about the nature of the Reign of God, meaning what the world looks like when we all are living according to the love of God.  Those stories force the listener to think and to use their imaginations as they try to grasp the message that Jesus came into the world to deliver.  It was a standard method of rabbis of the time, a way to force their students to learn what was most essential by actually using their brains.


But John doesn’t usually roll like that.  Instead, this much more intimate Gospel tends to record challenging and highly symbolic conversations.  Unlike Mark and Matthew and Luke, the focus of those conversations is not God’s Kingdom here on earth, but Jesus talking about how he personally is living that out.  This is who I am, Jesus says.  This is how you can be.


Here, though, he tells a story.  That makes this little section of John unusual, because it almost...almost...is a story.  Jesus begins with the story of a sheepfold, an enclosure in which livestock would be kept safe from predators over the course of an evening.  There was just one way in, and one way out, and as Jesus spins out the story, he presents himself as a shepherd leading sheep into the fold.


The gate is opened, and the sheep follow the voice of their shepherd, and...a hand goes up in the back of the room.


“Um, Jesus?  We...er...ah...don’t quite get what it is you’re talking about.”


“Excuse me?”


“You know, the gate thing.  And the sheep.  Are we the sheep?  Are you the shepherd?  What is the sheepfold?  And if you’re the shepherd, who’s the gatekeeper?  Does the gatekeeper look like Sigourney Weaver?”


It’s clear that they don’t get it, not at all.  And so Jesus takes another swing at it.


“I am the...um...gate for the sheep,” he says, completely changing metaphors.  He then makes reference to “all those who came before” as being thieves and bandits, which most scholars take to mean those messianic figures that came before him.  “Enter by me,” he says.  “Have life, and have it abundantly.”


Our passage wraps up there, but if you go on one more verse...well, he’s right back to talking about being the good shepherd again.


What’s fascinating about this little passage is that there’s a peculiar tension.  


On the one hand, throughout John’s Gospel Jesus gives us images of a single path, a single Way.  He is clearly presenting himself, his person, his Way of being, as the Way to stand in right relationship with God.  Follow this teaching, he says, and all will be well.


That’s great, we say.  Tell us the one thing we need to know, and we’ll be done with it.  We like things nice and simple and straightforward.  Do this, do that, do the next thing, and then you’ll have reached the solution.


“I am the Way, the Truth, and the Life,” says Jesus, elsewhere in John.  Christians are particularly fond of that passage, because it’s really simple, and it makes us feel we’ve got the answer right and everyone else is just out of luck.  We like that.


But then there’s the other hand.  Jesus makes a point of describing this one great truth in dozens of different ways.  He explains it using story after story, image after image.  They are all different, each one framing the same great Truth from a different perspective and using a different image.  He does not hit us with one slogan, over and over again, like Don Draper trying to get a brand identity stuck in our heads.  The Kingdom of God!  I’m loving it!  Just do it!  It’s finger lickin’ good!


That’s not how he teaches.  He gives us stories and symbols, and comes at who he is and what he taught from dozens of different angles.


In that tension between one simple path and the many ways of telling it, we find the challenge for our own faith and our own journey.
We are to follow that path, but each of us with our own gifts and in our own way.


Let that be so, for you and for me, AMEN.







The Stranger At Your Side

Right.  So for this Sunday, well, I'd written a sermon.  It was all done.  But then, Saturday night, I realized that it wasn't the sermon that I wanted to preach.

So the embed below is semi-off-the-cuff.  Meaning: no text.  No outline.  Just the message that wanted to be preached instead of the one I'd put all that effort into writing.


All the Relevant Data

Poolesville Presbyterian Church
Rev. David Williams; 04.27.14

Scripture Lesson: John 20:19-31


Knowledge is a funny thing.

We like knowing, and knowing what we’re doing.  We like being aware, in the most general way, of the parameters of our engagement with the world.  

Flying blind into something seems like the best way to get completely messed up.  Oh, sure, we might be completely confident in our abilities, totally sure of ourselves.  But confidence can only carry you so far, we remind ourselves.  Sure, we can fire that motorcyle up.  But when it comes time to twist the throttle, we don’t want to go barreling into a roadside sign like Pee Wee Herman.

We need information.  And so there is a very human tendency to focus our energies on finding out more.  We want to try before we buy.  We want to do the research.  We don’t want to be vested in something until we have a complete understanding of every last detail, and every possible parameter.

Before we can proceed, we tell ourselves, the matter needs more study.

And I realize we’re outside the Beltway here, but y’all spend enough time inside that burning ring of fire to know what saying something needs more study means.  It means that somewhere, someone wants to make sure that nothing ever happens.  It needs more study is basically a bureaucratic death ray.  There is no better way to kill a new thing than to hit it with an analysis paralysis beam.

As much as it pains my Presbyterian soul to say it, almost any simple, basic, essentially good thing can be blasted into oblivion by overthinking it.  Something remarkably easy can be turned into something remarkably hard, if you do not find it in yourself to trust.

I’ve always been a critical overthinker. Like, say, in high school, whenever I’d contemplate whether or not it might be appropriate to mention to a particular someone that I liked them.  Should I tell her?  I’d weigh the variables in my mind, trying to play out every possible scenario.  But if I say this, she might think that.  And if I say that, she might respond in thus and such a way.

I’d try to anticipate every single possible response, and then carefully construct the most positive possible answer, until I’d arrived at the scenario that seemed least likely to result in either mortal embarrassment or some other disaster.  I was ready.

Of course, by this point, I’d been in college for eighteen months.

When our need to grasp things extends to the point where we find ourselves unable to act, unable to move, unable to engage with a new and potentially joyful thing, then we’ve managed to let our fear govern us.  We have allowed our doubt about something to consumer our ability to engage with it.

That’s a particular challenge when it comes to engaging with our faith, because we are always and ever finding ourselves wanting to base our actions on what we know with certainty.

That’s the core of the message about doubt that we hear in John’s Gospel this morning, the tale that has become known as the story of Doubting Thomas.  It begins with the disciples gathered in a house, tight knit and fearful behind locked doors.

Their fear makes sense, because even though it was just after the events of Easter, and they’d heard reports of some amazing things happening from Mary Magdalene, things were still far from settled.  Their rabbi was dead, or probably dead, or mostly dead, or something they couldn’t quite figure out.  Mary kept telling them, “I have seen the Lord,” but they were skeptical.  More than skeptical.  They were terrified.

Having seen him die, they weren’t particularly eager to go that route themselves.  And so we hear they’re gathered around in the house, “for fear of the Jews,” our Bibles say.

This seems a little weird, to be honest.  Not the fear part.  Generally, most of us have that reaction when presented with the very real likelihood of being crucified.  “I might be killed horrifically?  Eh, doesn’t bother me much.”

It’s the “fear of the Jews” bit that makes less sense.  Every single person in that room would have thought of themselves as Jewish.  James isn’t going to glance over at Peter and shriek “Aaaaah!  A Jew!”  There are two ways to think of this.  First, John’s Gospel is the latest and last of the stories of Jesus to reach final written form, perhaps sometime between 50 and 70 years after the life of Jesus.  By the time it was written, Judaism and Christianity were very distinct, and the Greek speaking Gentiles who were the likely audience for this Gospel would have felt themselves to be very much apart from Judaism.  

Another option is that the word judaioi, which is the Greek word used here for “Jews,” might actually mean “Judeans,” the urban people who lived in the southern kingdom, particularly in and around Jerusalem.  The disciples would all have been rural galileioi, Galileans, who spoke and dressed in very different ways.  It’d be a bit like a bunch of folks from Kentucky hiding away in terror in an apartment in New York city for fear of “the Americans.”  Yeah, they’re *technically* from the same country, but really, they’re not.  Really, not.

Whichever way, these frightened souls have a visitation, the arrival of a Jesus who brings them a word of shalom, of peace.  He gives them peace, he gives them the the great gifts of the true church.  He gives them the Holy Spirit, and he gives them the power to forgive.  And then, he’s gone.

This is where Thomas comes in.  It’s not clear quite why he wasn’t there in the first place.  Maybe they’d sent him out to get beer.  He gets back, and they say the same thing to him that Mary Magdalene had said to them.  “We have seen the Lord!”

And Thomas stands there, with the case of Pabst Blue Ribbon in his hand, and he shakes his head.  “What, are you kidding me?  Seriously, no.”  He wants evidence, and it’s hard to blame him.  Show me, he says.  It’s easy to read his demands as being overly aggressive and a bit bloody.  “I won’t believe until I stick my fingers in his wounds,” he says, and we say, “ew.”  But though his requirements put the viscera in visceral, he doesn’t ask for more than Jesus showed the others.

A week passes, and the doors are still locked, and somehow ninja Jesus manages to slip in again.  He offers them the same shalom, the same peace, and then has a little chat with Thomas.  He does not attack him.  Instead, he says, “Here I am.  Here’s my hand.  Here’s my side.  Go ahead.  Just don’t doubt, but believe.”

Thomas does, but we still struggle a bit with it.  We struggle because doubt seems to be a necessary part of who we are.  We struggle because while there may be brief moments of clarity and certainty in our lives, there are other times when we are less clear and less sure about both the path before us and the robustness of our knowing.

Do not doubt, but believe?  It seems impossible.  Doubt is always there in us.

Here, I’ve always found the writing of 20th century German existentialist theologian Paul Tillich helpful.  Yes, he’s a little dense and hard to read.  20th century German existentialist theologians aren’t like reading the Hobbit, although they are *great* for putting your kids to sleep at bedtime.  Yes, Tillich tends to use words that stretch even the most robust vocabulary.  I was reading one of his books of theology years ago, and came across a word I’d never ever seen.  When I looked it up, the “example” sentence for usage was exactly the same sentence I was reading.

But his way of putting doubt into the context of faith really works.  If we are completely certain of a thing, we grasp it totally, and there’s nothing about it we do not know?  Then we do not have faith.  If we can explain everything, and be totally and utterly confident in our explanations?  We do not have faith.

Like hope, faith isn’t a hard and fast thing.  It is the thing we do not completely grasp, but allow ourselves to be moved by.  It is the state of being that is beyond us, but that we trust enough to guide us.

Let that be so, for you and for me, AMEN.


The One We Can’t See

Poolesville Presbyterian Church
Easter Sunday 2014; Rev. David Williams

Scripture Lesson: John 20.1-18



We can miss things, miss them completely, and be staring right at them.

Mostly, it has to do with our being really small creatures.  Like this morning, if you got up early for the Easter Sunrise Service up there on Sugarloaf.  Four thirty in the Ey Em, if you’re coming from Annandale.  You get up, and you clamber out of bed, and you heave yourself into the shower, which you wish by some miracle would actually be a shower of coffee.  Yeah, you wouldn’t get clean, but you really wouldn’t care.

Then it’s out into the day, only it isn’t day, it’s far before morning, long before the earth rotates around and brings that star we orbit into view.  The day has not yet begun, and when you look up heavenward, you see that darking dome, sprinkled with points of light.

Though you’re looking right at it, you can’t quite process what it is you’re looking at.  It’s a funny thing, about the sky in the early morning.  Oh, sure, we know what we’re looking at, and we know all about the distances involved.  Neither our eyes or our minds can quite grasp what we’re staring into, this immensity.  We see twinkle twinkle little stars, our mind spooling out a two-dimensional dome above us.  That sense of volume, of depth, an impossible depth stretching out to the fastness, that’s lost to us.  We’re looking right at it, and we can’t recognize what we see.

It’s like when you look into the face of your newborn child, just hours old.  You see that little tiny baby in your hands, that scrunchy-faced bit of a thing, and you don’t have a clue who you’re looking at.  Oh, they may have a name, assuming you didn’t just get lost in the sea of options.  And they may look a little like someone, more like the mom or more like the dad.

But in your hands, you hold a life that has within it potentials that are completely beyond you.  Behind those little eyes, struggling to focus on a world that just suddenly got a whole lot larger and brighter, there rests the possibility of a person that you do not yet know.  You hear that little voice...well, not so little, when they want you to do something...and yet you can’t hear them singing.  You don’t hear the voice of the woman or the man they will become.

You can stare at them all day long, and often, you do.  You just sit there at the side of their crib, and look at that sleeping face...finally sleeping, thank you Jesus...and still not know the truth of who it is they will be.

That message is the same as the Easter message we’ve heard in John’s Gospel this morning.  The message is one of a powerful transformation, of a shift from brokenness to grace, from ruins to a new being.  It’s a hard thing to see and move towards, because we really struggle to see it.  It’s the kind of thing we can’t wrap our brains around, like the immensity of the heavens.  It’s the kind of thing that is completely beyond us, like the future that rests before that child in our arms.   

Even if it’s right there in front of us, we struggle to see it and understand what it means.

It’s like Mary Magdalene, standing there, weeping at the empty tomb.  She’d discovered it, on her way to mourn, and rushed back to tell everyone who cared about him that things were not copacetic back at the tomb.

Others come, and they look around, and they see nothing.  They leave, and she stays.

Then there are some random strangers, chilling in their white rhinestone leisure suits.  She’s otherwise occupied, and is unphased by their appearance, and so they ask her why she’s crying, and she tells them.  Not just of her loss, but that now, she doesn’t even have what she needs to properly mourn.  Not even a body.  

And then there’s a man with her, asking her why she’s crying.  She looks up at him, her vision clouded by her tears.

He asks the same question, and she asks if maybe, just maybe, he knows where the body is.  “Tell me, and I’ll take him away,” she says.

He speaks her name, and suddenly, she sees.  She knows who he is, and she knows who she now can be.

The heart of Easter is that story of resurrection, of having our eyes opened to a new way of living that transcends death itself.  It’s a story that first plays its way out by the empty tomb, in a garden, in a conversation between a woman and this strange man who seems like an unknown, and yet becomes known.

Where there had been the certainty of death and loss, Mary is opened to the possibility of something so wonderful that she could barely bring herself to see it.   

That, for us, is the heart of the the resurrection promise we proclaim this morning, as we bear witness that things can be made new.

Because as difficult as it might be for us to look up at the face of the heavens and see them for what they are, and as much as we might struggle to grasp just what we’re seeing when we look in the face of that little one, we struggle most mightily to grasp who it is we are to become.  That person that we are not yet, that self that we have not yet encountered, we have trouble perceiving that.

It’s us, of course, but we don’t yet know what that looks like.  It’s easy, in our yearning to make ourselves, to become just more of what we know.  We can allow ourselves to be trapped in the tombs of our making, dead to newness, dead to the promise that rests in all of us.

But on this day, we trust that our renewal in body and spirit comes from God, who we know through Christ and his teachings.  It comes from God’s own Son, living a life filled with God’s own Spirit.  In the recognition and in the joy felt by Mary, we have a taste of what that truly new life is like.

It’s not just a materially successful life, not as the world defines it.   It’s not wealth.  It’s not power.  It’s real newness.  It’s change that transforms our view of the past, alters our  actions in the present, and sets a bright hope to guide us towards our future
It’s a recommitment to newness of joy, and a renewal of our life, every day.  It is the hope of restoration, of a city that rises from the ruins in which the only tears are tears of joy.  It is the hope of transformation, of a stone rolled away and a life made new.

On this Easter morning, see this with new eyes.

On this Easter morning, live this joy with a new heart.


He is risen.  Alleluia, AMEN.

Facepalm Sunday

Poolesville Presbyterian Church
04.13.14; Rev. David Williams

Scripture Lesson: Matthew 21:1-11




There are some things, now, that are a little hard to understand.  There’s a peculiar new shift in language, something having to do with our slow transition away from being people who can actually read to people who can only look at pictures of kittens.

Among the new words we might not understand is one that wasn’t around 20 years ago: meme.  “Meme” is a unit of cultural data, a bit of information that is passed along from person to person, kind of like a gene is passed from generation to generation.  Now, it tends to involve pictures of kittens.

Another new word is a mix of two others.  Face and palm give us “Facepalm,” that movement you make when someone says something so impossibly oblivious that your head sinks down in despair, resting in your hand.  Face, meet palm.

These things, we get.  But there are some things I just can’t get, and have never been able to quite grasp.  Like, say, the concept of “winning.”  On the surface, that would seem like a pretty basic one.

There’s something to be said for winning, for triumphing, for coming out on top.  I’ll freely admit that it doesn’t happen often in my own existence.  That fierce competitiveness, the intensity of our aggressive culture, I seem to have missed out on it somehow.  I like doing my best, but I just don’t have that killer instinct.

But compete we do.

It’s a peculiar form of madness, which was everywhere last month.  March Madness is done now, finally, and I notice it even though I suffer from Sports Enthusiasm Deficiency Disorder.  Honestly, I’m glad we’re done with March, because it’s starting to freak me out a little bit.  Maybe it’s the reinforcing effect of the social media echo chamber.  I pop onto Facebook to see how my friends are doing, and they’re all talking about brackets, and sharing brackets, and making up brackets that involve prominent figures from modern Christianity and superheroes and global political figures.  I wake up on March mornings, haunted by the fear that I’ll go outside, and everyone I know and love will be shambling around with dead eyes, mumbling the word “brackettttts” over and over to themselves.

And in those brackets, there is just a single winner, just one who makes it.  From Connecticut, or so I’m told, although why Connecticut as a state should be so dominant eludes me.  Maybe there’s a special place in America’s heart for a team named after extra large boys clothing.  

We approach so much of life as conflict, and in some ways that’s a good thing. Being competitive strengthens us.  It pushes us.  It drives us to stretch ourselves. Striving with another person makes us stronger, just as straining against a weight builds us up.

But when we view our whole world in terms of conflict, when we look at everything in the binary and polarizing terms of our victory and their loss, we create a world that looks a certain way.  We establish a way of relating to other persons that defines them as either our adversary or the opposing team.

That’s fine when it’s a game, something done for mutual enjoyment, and for mutual strengthening.

But in the world, as a way of understanding everything?  As a way of running a political system, or a legal system, or an economy?  It often causes more harm than good.  It creates adversarial relationships that do not need to exist. It turns us from those around us who may have something to offer, and instead drives us to view every moment as time to be in conflict.  That approach to living just drives us away from being able to see others with a heart of compassion.

And it is the way of human relating that sits at the heart of the Palm Sunday error, the fundamental misunderstanding of who Jesus was that colors every retelling of this story every year we retell it.

If you’ve ever been to a Palm Sunday service before, or if you learned about this story as a child, then you probably have a mental image of what I just read to you. There’s Jesus riding into town on a donkey, and he’s coming through the gates of the city, and everyone is waving these fronds in the air and hosannahing like they just don’t care.

That’s certainly the story we get in the other Gospels.  But it’s not the story we’ve just heard, not if we were listening closely.   Matthew, earnest and eager and passionate about finding connections between everything Jesus ever did and the stories from the Torah and prophets.

In Matthew’s story of Jesus, the tale gets told a little bit differently.  He takes a quotation about the arrival of the messiah from the prophet Zechariah (14:4), pitching out to us the vision that the one will arrive riding a donkey.  Well, not just a donkey.

Hebrew poetry doubles things up when it wants to emphasize something.  Many of the Psalms and sayings of the prophets end that way, saying the same thing again in a slightly different way to make sure you haven’t missed it the first time.  I do that with kids all the time myself.

What’s being emphasized is the humbleness of the mount.  This is a small, mild, and nonthreatening beast of burden, not the noble steed of a mighty king, but another kind of creature entirely.  This isn’t a mighty stallion, or even an elephant.  This is nothing like Prince Ali’s arrival scene from Aladdin, kids, and it’s not just because there’s no Robin Williams genie or 95 white persian monkeys.  

Matthew wrote like a Jewish scribe, meaning he was eager to double-down on every scripture that might have possibly in some way pointed to Jesus.  And so, unlike Mark, Luke and John, Matthew gives us Jesus riding not one, but two donkeys, which I honestly have a little trouble visualizing.  

He’s “sitting on them both?”  

In my more mischievous moments, I see Matthew’s Jesus riding them like a dolphin rider at Seaworld, one foot on one, one foot on another like he’s donkey-skiing into Jerusalem.  

But that’s just being silly.  Jesus enters the city, and the story Matthew pitches out to us covers that, more or less.

As the story tells it, everyone in Jerusalem thought the arrival meant there would soon be triumph, that it spoke to them finally finding their way to the place where the whole of their world would recognize who he was.  The world had been cruel to the people of Judah, and they were looking, eagerly, for their savior.  They understood that savior as the meshiach, the anointed one, the king who would come and set the whole world right again.

But from atop that donkey, the smell of animal and dust and sweat strong about him, Jesus saw where he was very differently.    He knew, as the crowds and his disciples did not, what this arrival meant.   It did not mean the crushing and humiliating defeat of Herod and Rome.  It did not mean angelic armies, or God showing up with face-melting death beams like at the end of Raiders of the Lost Ark to smite the infidels with a big smitey smiting.

He saw, as the Judeans in Jerusalem did not, that Jerusalem itself and the power struggles around it meant nothing.  Why would he want to overthrow that power?  Why would he desire to take it for himself?  Soon enough, it would be nothing, shattered and smoldering after Rome had annihilated it.  And then, in just a blink of an cosmic eye after that, the false glory that was Rome would tear itself to pieces, just as every empire does.

The most peculiar part of what Jesus proclaimed was that it wasn’t just about one group winning out over another.  He was not there just to give the Judeans victory over their Roman oppressors.  He was not bringing them the thing they were cheering for.

What Jesus had been teaching was different.  What he saw was rather different.  Jesus saw redemption and love, and the path of compassion.  And in the cheering of that crowd, in their yearning for victory, Jesus would have heard them not getting it.  

They didn’t get that compassion, radical and fundamental, was at the heart of the message that carries through this most holy of Christian seasons.  They didn’t understand that the reconciliation and hope Jesus brought was not just theirs, but was also intended to restore their enemies.  It was not just meant for them.

And from that misunderstanding, so written into our sacred story, it is maybe better not to think of this as Palm Sunday.  It’s more Facepalm Sunday, that day when Jesus rests his face in his hand, the shouting throng around him, and says, “Oh, me, they really really don’t have a clue what I’ve been talking about.” 

And to be honest, we still struggle with this.  We struggle with it as we look out to those who are different, to those who stand in opposition to us.  Our task, if we take what Jesus taught us seriously, is not to destroy them.  It is not to prosper at their expense.  It is not to rout them, but to find a way to love them as God does.

In this sacred season, take that out into the world with you. 


Let that be so, for you and for me, AMEN.